Why universities are failing: 4. Evidence denial

Contributions to evidence-based decision making, or management (EBM) or evidence based policy, or practice, is so frequently touted as the essence of scholarly output these days that most folk are unaware that universities as organisations are lousy at practicing what they espouse for their academics.  University management and administration consistently fail to ‘walk the talk’.

As this post, supportive of EBM indicates, the approach, some might say mantra, has been widely adopted in health, the law, business and management.   There are well formulated critiques of EBM.

In this posting I will outline how the research on performance management (e.g. KPIs or Key Performance Indicators) provides evidence that KPIs do not work.  I will also outline how the role of the big consulting firms systematically undermines university effectiveness by introducing and recycling plans and actions that defy research findings (often by scholars in the universities in which they operate) and sit outside both ethical approval and effective monitoring and evaluation. In addition I point to how the legacy of interventions by consultants from the big firms regularly undermine organisational learning and memory and commit senior managers of Universities, particularly those aspiring to career advancement, to a treadmill of dysfunctionality.  Finally I draw on a recent report by Ben Martin of SPRU that draws many lines of argument together:

Ben Martin (2015). What is Happening to our Universities? SPRU Working Paper Series
(SWPS), 2016-03: 1-26. ISSN 2057-6668. 

 Let me start by reprising the abstract from Ben Martin’s recent report:


“In recent decades, many universities have been moving in the direction of a more hierarchical and centralised structure, with top – down planning and reduced local autonomy for departments . Yet the management literature over this period has stressed the numerous benefits of flatter organisational structures, decentralisation and local autonomy for sections or departments. What might explain this paradox? And why have academics remained strangely quiet about this, meekly accepting their fate? The paper critically examines the dangers of centralised top-down management, increasingly bureaucratic procedures, teaching to a prescribed formula, and research driven by assessment and performance targets, illustrating these with a number of specific examples. It discusses a number of possible driving forces of these worrying developments, and concludes by asking whether academics may be in danger of suffering the fate of the boiled frog.”

The myths of performance management are widely known and supported by evidence e.g. Warwick Business School’s Dr Pietro Micheli; these results have been widely reported whether in ‘Psychology Today‘ or Information Management or in the field of Production Operations Management. Writing for Psychology Today, Ray Williams summarises the findings of many when he says:

“Performance measurement systems have proliferated in the past 20 years, with executives in both the private and public sectors relying on performance metrics for strategic planning, and decision-making to drive bottom line results. Yet research .. reveals for the most part performance management systems have been a failure in most organizations.”

Simon Caulkin writing about the future of work notes:

“The other mismatch is opening up in companies, and may be as tricky to fix. Philosopher Michael Polanyi’s paradox (“we can know more than we can tell”, or our tacit knowledge of the world exceeds our ability to spell it out) posits, for now, some limits to automation — notably the qualities humans took millions of years to evolve, such as curiosity, creativity, imagination, empathy and morality. But to yield dividends, these qualities need time, patience and deep attention, all of which have been expunged from high-pressure, performance-managed offices.”

http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/j.1467-923X.1995.tb00476.x/abstract

PERFORMANCE IMPROVEMENT IN PUBLIC SERVICES

  1. ROY MADRON
Article first published online: 24 AUG 2005
DOI: 10.1111/j.1467-923X.1995.tb00476.x
Issue
The Political Quarterly

The Political Quarterly

Volume 66, Issue 3, pages 181–194, July 1995

http://www.guardian.co.uk/public-leaders-network/2012/jul/25/big-debate-performance-management

http://www.guardian.co.uk/public-leaders-network/2013/feb/08/civil-service-performance-management-culture

http://www.guardian.co.uk/society/2013/apr/09/public-sector-services-hold-up-despite-cuts

http://www.guardian.co.uk/society/2012/jan/12/management-consultants-paid-7m-gps?INTCMP=SRCH

http://www.guardian.co.uk/business/2006/aug/27/theobserver.observerbusiness2?INTCMP=SRCH

Ben Martin (2015). What is Happening to our Universities?. SPRU Working Paper Series
(SWPS), 2016-03: 1-26. ISSN 2057-6668. Available at www.sussex.ac.uk/spru/swps2016-03

https://www.timeshighereducation.com/news/centralising-universities-ignores-evidence-what-works-best

https://www.sussex.ac.uk/webteam/gateway/file.php?name=2016-03-swps-martin.pdf&site=25

Related Posts