I have railed against the misuse and abuse of modelling, particularly economic modelling in many fora, including on this blog (e.g. August 8, 2008). Now Ross Gittins, whose views readers of this Blog will know I respect, has written claiming “Time to take a stand against misleading modelling“
I’d say models are a cartoon caricature of the economy, quite incapable of answering the intricate questions we ask of them.”
These are the orthodox financial prejudices that have, with brief exceptions, held sway ever since – in Gladstone’s red box as much as Thatcher’s handbag. When the 2008 economic storm hit (a metaphor which itself does ideological work, implying an act of nature rather than a crisis of human folly) the then shadow chancellor Osborne reached for a tried and tested script. “The cupboard is bare,” he sternly announced, likening bankrupt Britain to an over-indebted home.
So the household metaphor is deeply misleading but it remains irresistible to politicians and powerful with the public. It offers a way to make sense of the otherwise baffling billions in national debt through analogy with everyday experience. Furthermore, explains Jonathan Charteris-Black, an expert on rhetoric at the University of the West of England, it embeds “one of the most widely used of all political images: the nation as family, with the government as responsible parent”.”
Whilst modelling remains the main form of praxis of economists and the purveying of conceptually dead metaphors a major aspect of political and journalistic praxis it seems to me there is little scope to break out of the traps we set for ourselves by what we do when we do what we do!
